The Greatest St. Louis Cardinals of All Time

Ranker Baseball
Updated August 8, 2024 77.2K views 81 items
Ranked By
53.3K votes
5.1K voters
18 reranks
Voting Rules
Please only rank the players based on their time with the Cardinals

When looking at the history of baseball, it is undeniable how the St. Louis Cardinals have carved out an indelible legacy powered by their incredible roster of legendary players. Unmistakably, the team's tale boasts contributions from some high-caliber athletes who've left a renowned legacy in baseball. With no shortage of talent, the Cardinals lineup has consistently included players whose skills have echoed across the sport and acted as a yardstick for excellence. 

The St. Louis Cardinals have an unbroken tradition of recruiting the top players of the baseball world. Every athlete who wore their emblem carried a distinctive style of play that augmented the team's prominence. All of them entrenched themselves in the mainstay of pop culture, thereby fortifying their positions among the best St Louis Cardinals ever to grace the ballgame. In their individual ways, these players showcased extraordinary skills that set them leagues apart, earning them a permanent place in the annals of Cardinals history. 

Key figures who come to mind are Stan Musial, Bob Gibson, and Albert Pujols. Their outstanding contributions to the team’s legacy are simply undeniable. Stan Musial, a fine hitter with a unique corkscrew stance, was the heart and soul of the Cardinals team during his tenure. Comparatively, Bob Gibson, with his lethal combination of fastballs and sliders, was a symbol of fear for the opposing side. Meanwhile, Albert Pujols, known for his power and precision, was an irreplaceable part of the lineup. Each athlete showcased exceptional talents that set him apart and affirmed his rank among the best St. Louis Cardinals players. 

The history of the St. Louis Cardinals is rich with anecdotes of players who have left a deep-rooted legacy. Engaging with the history of the lives and careers of these great athletes provides a deeper understanding of why they are considered the best Cardinal players of all time. Their tales of triumph will continue to inspire future generations, keeping alive the legacy of this esteemed franchise. Expect to be impressed and moved by their stories, pivotal moments, and incredible performances that have collectively shaped the team's illustrious history. 

Most divisive: Mike Matheny
Over 5.1K Ranker voters have come together to rank this list of St. Louis Cardinals
Ranked by
  • Stan Musial
    1
    2,366 votes
    Dec. at 92 (1920-2013)
  • Bob Gibson
    2
    2,019 votes
    Age: 89
  • Albert Pujols
    3
    2,449 votes
  • Ozzie Smith
    4
    2,010 votes
  • Lou Brock
    5
    1,749 votes
    Age: 85
  • Yadier Molina
    6
    1,982 votes